Suzanne Morphew: When the Evidence and the Court Deadlines Don’t Line Up

Suzanne Morphew and Barry Morphew case banner

Suzanne Morphew: When the Evidence and the Court Deadlines Don’t Line Up

What changed

Suzanne Morphew was reported missing on Mother’s Day in 2020. For more than three years, the people looking for her had no answer about where she was. The discovery of her remains in September 2023 ended that part of the search. It also brought physical evidence into a renewed prosecution that now has to account for how the evidence is kept, examined and presented. Barry Morphew pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and is presumed innocent. 9 3

On November 13, Judge Amanda Claire Hopkins scheduled a two-day hearing beginning March 10, 2027, at 9 a.m. The order names two October 29 defense filings about forensic work. One asks the court to set a cutoff for the prosecution’s testing. The other asks for permission to raise issues that the defense says it could only identify after examining Suzanne’s remains or receiving later results. The order puts both issues on the hearing calendar. The requests themselves await a ruling in the public record reviewed for this article. 1 2 4 5

What the judge had already ordered

In May, Hopkins approved a procedure for consumptive testing, which can use up the material available for another examination. The prosecution must give the defense advance notice and a chance to respond. The court is to hold a hearing before authorizing such testing so the judge can set procedures and address preservation. 7

In June, the judge granted a broader preservation motion without objection. The order requires the prosecution to retain an equal amount of tested evidence for defense testing, preserve material that could help the defense or undermine a witness’s credibility, bring back evidence sent to other agencies for testing, and disclose chain-of-custody records and storage logs. Those records can help an examiner establish which item was tested and follow its movement between custodians. The orders establish the safeguards. The October filings do not establish that any sample was consumed or that a safeguard was breached. 6 7 4 5

Why the dates matter

The August scheduling order set November 2 as the general deadline for most pretrial motions, with exceptions including good cause. Four days before that deadline, defense counsel said their experts had yet to examine Suzanne’s remains and that the examination was expected after the deadline. In the same filing, counsel acknowledged that prosecutors were cooperating to arrange it. That detail matters because the dispute described in the filing can exist even when the parties are working together: a mutually arranged examination can still come too late for an expert’s findings to inform a motion. 3 4

The other timing problem starts in the lab. The defense said it believed the prosecution was still pursuing forensic work and asked the court to set a completion date. A result disclosed after a motion deadline can require an expert to review the report and its underlying data before counsel can identify a specific objection. The public filings reviewed here leave the testing inventory and release dates unresolved. They also leave open whether any later result will give either side a reason to ask the court to revisit the schedule. 4 5

The August order gives both sides the same 60-day deadline to disclose their intended trial experts. It calls for reports and the underlying facts or data, and it sets a later deadline for objections. In D-63, the defense proposed a 40-day window after receiving the prosecution’s disclosures to identify and disclose rebuttal experts. A lawyer can use an objection deadline to challenge an opinion. Finding a specialist, getting the underlying material reviewed and preparing any responsive opinion involves additional work. The November 13 hearing order specifically lists D-64 and D-65 and leaves the court discretion to take up other issues. D-63 is absent from the list. 3 8 1

What comes next

The March hearing is the next scheduled opportunity to hear the parties address D-64 and D-65. A written ruling could establish a testing cutoff, set conditions for supplemental filings, or explain how the existing dates will apply. The documents that would answer the remaining factual questions are the examination record, any testing notices and disclosure dates the parties put before the court, and the court’s ruling. The August order sets trial to begin July 19, 2027. 1 2 3

Suzanne’s family spent years waiting to learn where she was. The court’s next decisions concern how both sides will get to examine the evidence and what they can ask a jury to conclude from it.

Footnotes & Sources

Published .

  1. November 13 order setting the motions hearing
  2. Colorado Judicial Branch public case index
  3. August 7 amended scheduling order, paragraphs 5–6 and 13–16
  4. October 29 defense notice about examination and late testing, D-65
  5. October 29 defense motion for a testing deadline, D-64
  6. June 4 evidence preservation order, D-15
  7. May 19 order on consumptive testing, D-13
  8. October 29 defense motion on rebuttal experts, D-63
  9. Faces in the Footnotes, Suzanne Morphew case chronology
Approved October 24 burgundy and gold footer with Subscribe, Like, Share and Comment

Follow Faces in the Footnotes

Like this story

Leave a Reply